what happened to vice ganda and billy crawford

According to the search results, Vice Ganda and Billy Crawford had a long-time feud that started in 2019 when they unfollowed each other on Instagram. However, they reconciled and ended their years-long rift on November 9, 2023, during the live episode of "Its Showtime". Crawford, along with his wife Coleen Garcia and their son, were the surprise guests of the "Magpasikat" performance of Vice Ganda, Jackie Gonzaga, and Cianne Dominguez. After the production number, Vice Ganda and Crawford confirmed that they had a falling out, with the "Bright Lights" hitmaker publicly apologizing to the comedy superstar. Crawford shared that his ailing father wished for the reconciliation. Vice Ganda, meanwhile, explained how Garcia was instrumental in opening the communication lines between her and Crawford.