Aaron Rodgers is currently facing multiple issues affecting both his performance and reputation:
Physical and Performance Issues
- Rodgers is dealing with lingering injuries, including a significant Achilles injury suffered early in the 2023 season. Since returning, he has been "banged up" with various ailments like ankle and hamstring problems, which have accumulated and impacted his mobility and effectiveness on the field
- His physical decline is compounded by age (40 years old) and a loss of some athleticism that previously helped him excel
- On the field, Rodgers has struggled with poor mechanics, such as improper footwork, throwing off his back foot, and not going through his progressions properly. This has led to inaccurate throws and missed opportunities
- The Jets' offensive scheme and coaching have also been criticized. The offense lacks creativity and game-breaking potential despite having talented players. Rodgers' influence on team decisions and a lack of strong coaching leadership have contributed to dysfunction
- Rodgers has also been noted for holding the ball too long and trying to make highlight plays rather than executing fundamental football, which affects offensive efficiency
Off-Field and Reputation Issues
- Rodgers has been involved in several controversies, including misleading statements about his COVID-19 vaccination status and promoting conspiracy theories on public platforms like the Pat McAfee Show. These actions have damaged his public image and created distractions for his team
- He has a reputation for demanding significant control over team decisions, including personnel and coaching staff choices, which some see as overstepping boundaries and causing friction within organizations
- His outspoken nature and refusal to conform to media expectations have polarized fans and media alike, leading to a perception of him as either a misunderstood genius or an egotistical diva
In summary, Aaron Rodgers is struggling due to a combination of physical injuries, declining athleticism, suboptimal team environment and coaching, and off-field controversies that have overshadowed his on-field talents and contributed to a challenging period in his career
