The leading predictions for the winner of American Idol Season 23 (2025) focus on three finalists: John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Breanna Nix.
- John Foster is the favorite to win according to most polls and expert predictions. He is an 18-year-old country singer with a charming, radio-ready vocal tone and strong charisma. His style fits well with the show's history of favoring male country singers, as three previous country male winners have emerged in recent seasons. John has also gained millions of social media views and is seen as a confident and likable performer
- Jamal Roberts is considered the best all-around entertainer among the finalists. A physical education teacher from Mississippi, Jamal is praised for his dynamic performances, vocal range, and ability to connect emotionally with the audience. Judges and fans alike admire his talent, and some believe he should win even if John is predicted to take the crown. Jamal has also amassed significant social media attention
- Breanna Nix is expected to finish third. She is noted for her powerful vocal range and relatable backstory as a stay-at-home mom who struggles with self-confidence. Breanna shines in gospel and country genres and is likely to pursue a career in contemporary Christian music after the show
Poll results show over 50% of voters predict John Foster will win, while about 45% feel Jamal Roberts should win. The competition is expected to be a close race primarily between John and Jamal, with Breanna rounding out the top three
. Final prediction: John Foster is most likely to win American Idol 2025, with Jamal Roberts as a strong contender and Breanna Nix placing third
