Tiffany Derry left her role as one of the titans on Bobby's Triple Threat after three seasons to join MasterChef as a new judge. This transition offered her a bigger opportunity with a broader reach, more creative control, and involvement behind the scenes in shaping the show, rather than just competing or mentoring. She made this career move with the support and encouragement of Bobby Flay, the show's host and one of her mentors. Tiffany was replaced on Bobby's Triple Threat by Ayesha Nurdjaja for the show's fourth season, which returned in September 2025.